[Skip to main content](#vessel-content)

#   drop down listing for assigning menu items

##

- **[jackbat](/forum/user/6910-jackbat "View jackbat's Profile")**
- [![jackbat's Avatar](https://www.hikashop.com/media/kunena/core/svg/person.svg)](/forum/user/6910-jackbat "View jackbat's Profile") Topic Author
- [ Offline](/forum/user/6910-jackbat)

Less More

- Posts: 35
- Thank you received: 0
-
-

13 years 10 months ago [\#86255](#86255) by [jackbat](/forum/user/6910-jackbat "View jackbat's Profile")  *[drop down listing for assigning menu items](/forum/3-bug-report/77596-drop-down-listing-for-assigning-menu-items#86255 "I know that we have discussed this before and you were not very receptive to the issue, however having spent a few weeks with the software I think it is important enough to try one more time to make you understand the issue.  When you use the software the way that we do, essentially assigning a menu item to every product to integrate it with stories, joomla breadcrumbs, etc.... your mechanism for assigning the product page to the menu item of a drop down list becomes unmanageable really quickly. There is no categorization, filter, search or drill down possible. Essentially you have to remember exactly what the product was called and search through the scrolling list. We find ourselves having to go back to the products listing to get the exact wording of a product in order to find it in the product page menu listing.  I would ask you to at least consider that there are a number of more effective ways of doing this. Take for example the joomla Article manager which allows you to not only search on key words, but to drill down using categories and authors. Or even the Joomla menu system which certainly isn't perfect but at least you can filter by key words. Even the linking systems in the editor allows you to drill down through categories to get to what you are looking for.  In fact, even in your own software, when creating products / categories etc... you do an excellent job of allowing filtering and drilling down through categories. I would say that your product creation section is pretty much perfect and if you simply implemented that in the menu area it would be great.  Imagine if all of joomla only offered scrolling lists. It would not be a very scalable management site.  My concern is that as we continue to add products, that this will become simply unusable as the scrolling list gets to 400 or 500 items.  Frankly, I am not sure why you don't see the problem.  I have attached an image in case I am not making myself clear on what exactly the problem is.  As always, thank you for your time.  Jack")* was created by *[jackbat](/forum/user/6910-jackbat "View jackbat's Profile")*

I know that we have discussed this before and you were not very receptive to the issue, however having spent a few weeks with the software I think it is important enough to try one more time to make you understand the issue.

When you use the software the way that we do, essentially assigning a menu item to every product to integrate it with stories, joomla breadcrumbs, etc.... your mechanism for assigning the product page to the menu item of a drop down list becomes unmanageable really quickly. There is no categorization, filter, search or drill down possible. Essentially you have to remember exactly what the product was called and search through the scrolling list. We find ourselves having to go back to the products listing to get the exact wording of a product in order to find it in the product page menu listing.

I would ask you to at least consider that there are a number of more effective ways of doing this. Take for example the joomla Article manager which allows you to not only search on key words, but to drill down using categories and authors. Or even the Joomla menu system which certainly isn't perfect but at least you can filter by key words. Even the linking systems in the editor allows you to drill down through categories to get to what you are looking for.

In fact, even in your own software, when creating products / categories etc... you do an excellent job of allowing filtering and drilling down through categories. I would say that your product creation section is pretty much perfect and if you simply implemented that in the menu area it would be great.

Imagine if all of joomla only offered scrolling lists. It would not be a very scalable management site.

My concern is that as we continue to add products, that this will become simply unusable as the scrolling list gets to 400 or 500 items.

Frankly, I am not sure why you don't see the problem.

I have attached an image in case I am not making myself clear on what exactly the problem is.

As always, thank you for your time.

Jack

Please [Log in](/login?return=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuaGlrYXNob3AuY29tL2ZvcnVtLzMtYnVnLXJlcG9ydC83NzU5Ni1kcm9wLWRvd24tbGlzdGluZy1mb3ItYXNzaWduaW5nLW1lbnUtaXRlbXM/dG1wbD1tYXJrZG93bg==) or [Create an account](/component/users/registration?Itemid=101) to join the conversation.

- **[nicolas](/forum/user/63-nicolas "View nicolas's Profile")**
- [![nicolas's Avatar](https://www.hikashop.com/media/kunena/avatars/resized/size144/users/avatar63.png?1793428657)](/forum/user/63-nicolas "View nicolas's Profile")
- [ Offline](/forum/user/63-nicolas)

Less More

- Posts: 86576
- Thank you received: 14320
-
-

13 years 10 months ago [\#86418](#86418) by [nicolas](/forum/user/63-nicolas "View nicolas's Profile")  Replied by *[nicolas](/forum/user/63-nicolas "View nicolas's Profile")* on topic *[drop down listing for assigning menu items](/forum/3-bug-report/77596-drop-down-listing-for-assigning-menu-items#86418 "I know that we have discussed this before and you were not very receptive to the issue, however having spent a few weeks with the software I think it is important enough to try one more time to make you understand the issue.  When you use the software the way that we do, essentially assigning a menu item to every product to integrate it with stories, joomla breadcrumbs, etc.... your mechanism for assigning the product page to the menu item of a drop down list becomes unmanageable really quickly. There is no categorization, filter, search or drill down possible. Essentially you have to remember exactly what the product was called and search through the scrolling list. We find ourselves having to go back to the products listing to get the exact wording of a product in order to find it in the product page menu listing.  I would ask you to at least consider that there are a number of more effective ways of doing this. Take for example the joomla Article manager which allows you to not only search on key words, but to drill down using categories and authors. Or even the Joomla menu system which certainly isn't perfect but at least you can filter by key words. Even the linking systems in the editor allows you to drill down through categories to get to what you are looking for.  In fact, even in your own software, when creating products / categories etc... you do an excellent job of allowing filtering and drilling down through categories. I would say that your product creation section is pretty much perfect and if you simply implemented that in the menu area it would be great.  Imagine if all of joomla only offered scrolling lists. It would not be a very scalable management site.  My concern is that as we continue to add products, that this will become simply unusable as the scrolling list gets to 400 or 500 items.  Frankly, I am not sure why you don't see the problem.  I have attached an image in case I am not making myself clear on what exactly the problem is.  As always, thank you for your time.  Jack")*

Hi,

We are very well aware of the problem. The problem is not that we don't want to improve the interface. It's that like for any change, it takes time to do it.
We have hundreds of points on our todo list. Creating menu items for hundred of products is usually not something users do. It's usually used when you only have a small number of products and in that case, a dropdown is perfect. That's why we didn't do it yet, and focused on other things. But that doesn't mean that we don't want to change it.

We actually want to develop it during February for HikaShop 2.2. Next release of HikaShop, the 2.1, will be in one or two weeks, so the 2.2 should be around March.

Please [Log in](/login?return=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuaGlrYXNob3AuY29tL2ZvcnVtLzMtYnVnLXJlcG9ydC83NzU5Ni1kcm9wLWRvd24tbGlzdGluZy1mb3ItYXNzaWduaW5nLW1lbnUtaXRlbXM/dG1wbD1tYXJrZG93bg==) or [Create an account](/component/users/registration?Itemid=101) to join the conversation.

- **[jackbat](/forum/user/6910-jackbat "View jackbat's Profile")**
- [![jackbat's Avatar](https://www.hikashop.com/media/kunena/core/svg/person.svg)](/forum/user/6910-jackbat "View jackbat's Profile") Topic Author
- [ Offline](/forum/user/6910-jackbat)

Less More

- Posts: 35
- Thank you received: 0
-
-

13 years 9 months ago [\#86614](#86614) by [jackbat](/forum/user/6910-jackbat "View jackbat's Profile")  Replied by *[jackbat](/forum/user/6910-jackbat "View jackbat's Profile")* on topic *[drop down listing for assigning menu items](/forum/3-bug-report/77596-drop-down-listing-for-assigning-menu-items#86614 "I know that we have discussed this before and you were not very receptive to the issue, however having spent a few weeks with the software I think it is important enough to try one more time to make you understand the issue.  When you use the software the way that we do, essentially assigning a menu item to every product to integrate it with stories, joomla breadcrumbs, etc.... your mechanism for assigning the product page to the menu item of a drop down list becomes unmanageable really quickly. There is no categorization, filter, search or drill down possible. Essentially you have to remember exactly what the product was called and search through the scrolling list. We find ourselves having to go back to the products listing to get the exact wording of a product in order to find it in the product page menu listing.  I would ask you to at least consider that there are a number of more effective ways of doing this. Take for example the joomla Article manager which allows you to not only search on key words, but to drill down using categories and authors. Or even the Joomla menu system which certainly isn't perfect but at least you can filter by key words. Even the linking systems in the editor allows you to drill down through categories to get to what you are looking for.  In fact, even in your own software, when creating products / categories etc... you do an excellent job of allowing filtering and drilling down through categories. I would say that your product creation section is pretty much perfect and if you simply implemented that in the menu area it would be great.  Imagine if all of joomla only offered scrolling lists. It would not be a very scalable management site.  My concern is that as we continue to add products, that this will become simply unusable as the scrolling list gets to 400 or 500 items.  Frankly, I am not sure why you don't see the problem.  I have attached an image in case I am not making myself clear on what exactly the problem is.  As always, thank you for your time.  Jack")*

That's great. The last time I put this up I got the impression that you didn't think it was an issue. As long as I know you are aware and open to improvements, I am fine. We have been running an online store for over 10 years now, and I am hoping that we can stick with this implementation for a good long time.

Because of how we implement kits, options and so forth I imagine that we will push your software to where many people don't.

Thank you.

Please [Log in](/login?return=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuaGlrYXNob3AuY29tL2ZvcnVtLzMtYnVnLXJlcG9ydC83NzU5Ni1kcm9wLWRvd24tbGlzdGluZy1mb3ItYXNzaWduaW5nLW1lbnUtaXRlbXM/dG1wbD1tYXJrZG93bg==) or [Create an account](/component/users/registration?Itemid=101) to join the conversation.

Board Categories HikaShop Install &amp; Update Product &amp; Category Display Content Creation Sales and Orders Orders management Reports &amp; Statistics Customers Checkout Payment Methods Shipping Methods Import &amp; Export (CSV, XLS…) Specific Features Affilation Taxes Wishlist Vote Carousel &amp; Slider Mass Actions Filters &amp; Search Discount &amp; Coupon Feature Request Integrations Showcase General Talk about HikaShop Development HikaShop 3.0 Beta Translation Commercial Jobs HikaShop Components HikaMarket Market: Feature requests Market: How to? Market: Bug Report HikaSerial General talk about HikaSerial Serial: Bug Report Serial: How to? Support en Français de HikaSerial (French Support) HikaSubscription HikaAuction Auction: Feature requests Auction: How to? Auction: Bug report Hikashop around the world Support en Français (French Support) Russian FAQ. Курс выживания с Hikashop. Частые вопросы и о Расширения Hikashop Наши сайты на Hikashop 日本語版サポート(Japanese Support) Thai German Archives Bug Report How to?

[](/forum/topics/feed/mode-topics?format=feed&type=rss)

Time to create page: 0.054 seconds

[Powered by](/forum/credits) [Kunena Forum](https://www.kunena.org)
